SCOTUS Limits Extent of Miranda Rights for Criminals

The Supreme Court loosened the enforcement of Miranda rights for those convicted of crimes this week. They ruled that suspects who are not warned about their right to remain silent can’t sue a police officer for damages now under federal civil rights law. This will be true even if the evidence found is used against them in their trial. 

This decision will decrease a person’s protection against self-incrimination by keeping the criminal from seeking damages. But the ruling also means that when an officer fails to give the Miranda warning, it will not cause the officer to face potential damages in a civil lawsuit. And it will not impact whether or not the evidence can be used in a criminal trial. 

What the court was basically saying is that the Miranda warning protects a constitutional right, but the warning itself is not a right.

Steve Vladeck, a Supreme Court analyst for CNN and a professor at the University of Texas School of Law, said, “Today’s ruling doesn’t get rid of the Miranda right. But it does make it far harder to enforce. Under this ruling, the only remedy for a violation of Miranda is to suppress statements obtained from a suspect who’s not properly advised of his right to remain silent.”

There were six Republican-appointed justices, including Justice Samuel Alito, who ruled that a violation of the Miranda right “is not itself a violation of the Fifth Amendment. We see no justification for expanding Miranda to confer a right to sue.”

The specific case the High Court heard focused on Terence Tekoh. He was a hospital worker who was accused of sexually assaulting a female patent who was immobilized in 2014.

The issue was whether or not a defendant must be read his Miranda rights and whether he can sue the police for damages if he did not receive the Miranda warning and evidence was used against him in the criminal proceeding. 

Deputy Sued by Criminal Wins Case

A Los Angeles County sheriff’s deputy, Carlos Vega, questioned Tekoh but did not read him his rights as was required by the 1966 precedent in Miranda v. Arizona. In that case, the court held that a defendant has to be warned of a “right to remain silent.”

From that case forward, if the Miranda warning was not given, courts are not allowed to use any evidence found or any self-incriminating statements made while the defendant is being held in custody. 

Tekoh confessed to the crime and was tried but acquitted even after the confession was made public at his trial. He sued the officer under federal law, Section 1983. It allows lawsuits for damages against a government official for violating a person’s constitutional rights. 

It was Vega’s lawyer Roman Martinez that argued that Tekoh could not bring his claim because establishing a violation of Miranda does not establish a violation of the Fifth Amendment. 

Martinez praised the court’s ruling and said it “confirms that Deputy Vega cannot be sued for his good-faith effort to investigate the alleged sexual assault of a defenseless hospital patient.”

Looks like the Supreme Court got it right again. 

China Takes Aim at the United States Over Taiwan

China is once again flexing its muscles globally and staring down the United States as well. Military officials in the communist nation have declared to their U.S. counterparts that the

Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen Gives Specific Direction to IRS

Is somebody in the Biden Administration really thinking in the best interest of the middle-class family? It appears so. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen gave some direction to the Internal Revenue

FBI Raid of Trump’s Mar-A-Lago Estate Prompts Republican Anger and 2024 Speculation

The recent FBI raid of former President Donald Trump’s Mar-A-Lago, Florida estate has sent shock waves across the country, stirred up anger from Republicans and others, and ramped up speculation

What’s In and What’s Out in Biden’s Package of Compromise?

It was just a year ago that President Joe Biden’s policy agenda was dead on arrival with his multi-trillion-dollar Build Back Better package. The legislation failed to pass through Congress

Can Sanders and Warren Sleep at Night After Inflation Reduction Act Vote?

I wonder how Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, an independent, and Massachusetts Democratic Sen. Elizabeth Warren are sleeping at night? These two progressives have a long history of going after financial

Biden Administration: Monkeypox a Public Health Emergency

The Biden Administration declared the monkeypox outbreak a public health emergency. Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra issued a statement announcing the emergency: "In light of evolving

Jobs Report Released: Biden Touts Jobs Numbers, Says He Has Made ‘Significant Progress’ in Effort to ‘Rebuild the Middle Class’

President Joe Biden touted U.S. job growth after the release of the recent jobs report. "More people are working than at any point in American history," proclaimed Biden. He explained

Ron DeSantis: Suspends ‘Soros-Funded’ Prosecutor for ‘Ignoring the Law,’— Soars in Polls

Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis recently announced the immediate suspension of a Florida state attorney, Andrew Warren, after he failed to enforce state laws regulating abortion and dealing with crime. 

Rising Temperatures May Mean More Infectious Diseases

Professor Camilo Mora was bitten by a mosquito while visiting Colombia in 2014. It gave him the chikungunya virus and his joints still ache today. The professor now blames a

Cities Face Increasing Crisis as Fewer Kids Enroll and Schools Shrink

Schools that already experienced decreasing enrollment during the pandemic, with some schools in larger cities losing a third of their students, continue to suffer from disinvestment, causing a further exodus

Schumer

Wall Street Journal Editorial Board: Issues a Blistering Op-Ed on the ‘Schumer-Manchin Tax Increase

The Wall Street Journal editorial board recently published a scathing piece criticizing the reconciliation bill struck between Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and Senator Joe Manchin, D. W. Va. The

White House Economic Adviser: U.S. Better Off Than Countries Facing Famine

White House economic adviser Brian Deese recently said that while inflation in the U.S. is hurting Americans in their wallets, at least they're not "facing famine" like some other countries.

Pelosi Makes Waves Across the Pacific with Trip to Taiwan

U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi went to Asia even though Biden was against the trip, and she went toe to toe with China in her support of Taiwan. Pelosi said

Sen. Lindsey Graham Not Giving Up the Battle Against Georgia Subpoena

Even though most Americans are growing tired of the legal battles over the 2020 election, in Georgia, the story keeps plodding along. Sen. Lindsey Graham has asked former President Donald

Fed Not Prepared to Halt Chinese Information Gathering: Report

The Federal Reserve lacks systems adequate to counter a “malign” effort by China to gather inside information on the U.S. monetary policy and economy, according to a report prepared by

Will Voters Support Liz Cheney in the Coming Primary?

Rep. Liz Cheney certainly had her day in the spotlight with the January 6th House select hearings, but the sun is setting on this Wyoming politician. CNN recently traveled to

Trump Goes to Battle with Republican Leaders Over Election Ruling

Former President Donald Trump just cut loose on his Truth Social media site this weekend. His target was Wisconsin Assembly Speaker Robin Vos and U.S. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell

Association of American Medical Colleges Slammed for Forcing Critical Race Theory on Students

The group that sets the standards for medical education, The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC), recently released standards pushed by the far-left forcing students to study and apply its

Manchin Shocks the Dems and Stabs the GOP

Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) and Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) reached a secret agreement that sent shock waves through the Democratic Party and felt like a stab in the

DOJ: Warren Buffet-Owned Mortgage Company Discriminated Against Black and Latino Homebuyers

A Warren Buffet Berkshire Hathaway-owned Pennsylvania mortgage company discriminated against potential Latino and Black homebuyers in New Jersey, Delaware, and Philadelphia, according to the Department of Justice (DOJ), in what

Pentagon Official: “Only a Matter of ‘Time’ before China Causes’ Major’ Incident in Indo-Pacific Region

A top official at the Pentagon recently warned that it is "only a matter of time" before a "major incident or accident" occurs in the Indo-Pacific region. Speaking at an

Former White House Official Criticizes Vice President Mike Pence Upon Return to Washington D.C.

Both former Vice President Mike Pence and former President Donald Trump were back in Washington D.C. recently. I prompted some to draw a comparison between the two men. A former

Walmart Warns of Dark Economic Clouds Ahead

If you are looking for some economic good news, you won’t find it in Walmart for two reasons…the price of goods and there prediction about our economic future. Stocks went

Economists: U.S. Housing Market Could be Headed for ‘Meltdown’

Economists are warning the U.S. housing market could be on the verge of a “meltdown.” The warning follows the recent release of data showing a collapse in home builder confidence

More Bark from Biden on Climate Change

President Joe Biden sent a clear signal that his hopes of getting anything done in Congress are dead. He is scrambling now with the idea of taking executive actions on