How Boston Lost Its Case Against Request to Fly Christian Flag at City Hall

The Supreme Court ruled recently that Boston violated the free speech rights of a conservative activist when by refusing his request to fly a Christian flag on the City Hall flagpole.

The unanimous court decision was written by Justice Stephen Breyer and said the city discriminated against religious activist Harold Shurtleff because of his “religious viewpoint.”

The city has routinely approved applications to use one of its three flagpoles located outside City Hall for citizens to fly other chosen flags. The flagpoles usually fly the Boston, Massachusetts, and U.S. flags.

Shurtleff and his Camp Constitution organization requested to fly the Christian flag, a white flag with a red cross on a blue background located in a square in the upper left corner.

The request was made to mark Constitution Day, September 17, 2017.

Boston had approved 284 previous, consecutive applications to fly flags before rejecting Shurtleff’s because it was a Christian flag. The city suggested Shurtleff could fly a different flag or banner, but he refused, and the lower courts upheld the city’s decision.

However, the high court ruled that the city and lower courts were wrong.

Breyer wrote that the case hung on whether the flag-flying was an act of the government, which would mean Boston could do whatever it wanted, or an act of a private party expressing free speech, like Shurtleff.

A public forum

Justice Stephen Breyer wrote the court’s decision. He said the critical question in the case was whether the city of Boston had created a public forum by allowing private groups to utilize its flagpole or endorsing and choosing the flags it approves.

If a government entity speaks for itself, it is immune to scrutiny under the First Amendment.

Justice Breyer wrote, “Finally, we look at the extent to which Boston actively controlled these flag raisings and shaped the messages the flags sent. The answer, it seems, is not at all. And there is the most salient feature of this case.”

He continued saying the “city’s lack of meaningful involvement in the selection of flags or the crafting of their messages leads us to classify the flag raisings as private, not government, speech — though nothing prevents Boston from changing its policies going forward.”

Boston had previously said that if it lost the case at the Supreme Court, it would likely change its policy to take more control over what flags can be flown.

Shurtleff has used his Camp Constitution website and position as a former organizer with the John Birch Society to question the outcome of the 2020 election, who was behind the September 11 attacks, the January 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol, and the efficacy of Covid19 vaccines.

China Takes Aim at the United States Over Taiwan

China is once again flexing its muscles globally and staring down the United States as well. Military officials in the communist nation have declared to their U.S. counterparts that the

McCarthy Says He Will Form Select Committee on China If Elected Speaker

Republican leader in the U.S. House of Representatives, Kevin McCarthy, said recently he would form a select committee on China if he is elected speaker of the House, accusing President

Arizona County Board Delays Certifying Election Results, Cite Uncertified Counting Machines

The board overseeing a county in a county in Southeastern Arizona recently delayed certifying the results of last week’s vote after being contacted by individuals who claimed that counting machines

Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin Oversees ‘Woke’ Training for Our Military

If you love America’s military and are proud of our history in keeping the world safe for Democracy, you are going to have a real problem with what follows. Defense

Sen. Josh Hawley Has His Mic Drop Moment with FBI Director

It hasn’t been a good week for FBI Director Christopher Wray and his whole organization. He gave testimony for the House, and Rep. Clay Higgins (R-LA) asked him a question

Massive Migrant Group Hits the Texas Border as the End of Title 42 Looms

An enormous group of illegal immigrants in the hundreds have arrived at one portion of the southern border over the weekend. Border Patrol agents face crossings totaling tens of thousands

Judge Allows Deposition of FBI Agent Against Biden Censorship

It’s hard to argue that the White House has been working to create censorship across the nation. But the Biden Administration and the FBI just took a hard hit by

FBI Director Wray: Seventy Percent of FBI’s Abortion-Related Violence Cases Have Anti-Abortion Victims Since Dobbs

The director of the Federal Bureau of Investigations (FBI), Christopher Wray, recently testified that around 70% of the bureau’s abortion-related threat or violence cases after the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott Declares an Invasion at the Southern Border

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) declared an "invasion" at the chaotic southern border on Tuesday. He indicated that he would be taking "unprecedented measures ... to keep our state &

Iranian Parliament Votes for the Death Sentence Against 15,000 Protestors to Teach ‘Hard Lesson’

There have been multiple reports in the media about protests in Iran after the death of 22-year-old Mahsa Amini. She was killed after being beaten while in custody following her

GOP Takes Control of the House of Representatives

Democrats will no longer control Congress. Republicans have gained control of the House of Representatives, according to the Associated Press.  The AP is predicting Mike Garcia will win re-election in

Former President Donald Trump Announces 2024 Re-Election Bid for President

Former Republican President Donald Trump announced that he will again run for the GOP nomination for president in the 2024 election. Trump would like to return to the White House

Supreme Court Case on State Legislatures Could Open Litigation Floodgates

The Supreme Court is preparing to hear a case next month that could dramatically reshape how federal elections are conducted.  The case to be argued on December 7, Moore v.

Voters in Montana Reject Ballot Measure Requiring Medical Care for ‘Infants Who Are Born Alive’

In the recent midterm elections, Montana voters rejected the Born-Alive Infant Protection Act, which would have required medical professionals to give lifesaving medical care to newborns who were born prematurely

NYC Would Rather Shell Out $600 Million for Illegals Instead of Saying “No”

New York City residents already pay some of the highest taxes in the country. On top of federal and state taxes, many also pay county and city taxes on their

Dems Aim to Raise Debt Ceiling Before GOP Controls House

Congressional Democratic leaders vowed to quickly tackle the nation’s debt ceiling in the next few weeks, saying the party’s victory in the midterms has given them leverage, even while the

Trump Fires Warning Shots to DeSantis Amid Talk of 2024 Presidential Run

Former President Donald Trump is expected to announce a campaign for a 2024 White House bid. And he is laying some groundwork that has created a buzz around Florida Governor

McCarthy’s Quest for Speaker Position Collides with GOP Failures

With the expectation of a red wave quickly vanishing, Republicans faced the reality that any claim to power would mean leadership would preside of a narrowly divided Congress. The party’s

Pelosi Moves Quickly from Personal Suffering to Political Blaming

It was just a matter of time, and now House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has demonized the right for the recent hammer attack on her husband, Paul.  She appeared on CNN’s

Activists for Abortion Rights Score Major Midterm Victories Across the U.S. 

Voters across the U.S. delivered several decisive victories for the right to abortion in the first election since the overturn of Roe v. Wade in June by the Supreme Court.

“Definitely Not a Republican Wave, That’s for Darn Sure” — Bemoans Lindsey Graham After Lackluster GOP Performance”

Top Republicans, including Senators Ted Cruz and Lindsey Graham, admitted that the much-touted 'red wave' had not quite materialized as a Democrat in Nevada won a seat in the Senate

“Very Big Announcement”: Trump Says He Will Make a ‘Big Announcement’ on November 15

Former President Donald Trump is teasing a major announcement on November 15, which could signal a decision on a possible presidential run in 2024.  "Two years ago, we were a

New York Times Thinks It Has a ‘Gotcha’ on DeSantis, But It’s Just the Opposite

The left-driven New York Times published a wildly critical article over the weekend about Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis. The title of the article was “Pranks, Parties, and Politics: Ron

New York Governor Kathy Hochul Brushes off Crime Concerns, Mocks ‘Hyperventilating’ Lee Zeldin

Kathy Hochul, New York Governor, claimed challenger Lee Zeldin was “hyperventilating” over the issue of rising crime — only two hours after two subway riders were stabbed. One of the

Musk’s Responses to AOC’s Fit Are Worth Far More than $8 a Month

What a great show Elon Musk’s takeover of Twitter has been, the best part of it all is how the Democrat liberals keep throwing hissy fits in response to his